What to do...

Alright, so does anyone else have this problem? Or is it just me. When I take a picture (of nature especially) when I go to edit it, I don't know what to do. This is the problem. The picture straight out of the camera has a certain feel to it. The sky, the colors, it just sets a mood. But I know that it's not perfect so I want to edit it. However when I edit it, it seems to lose that mood. Does that make sense?! So even if the edited picture LOOKS better, it loses that feel...and I don't know what to do...Take this picture for instance.

This first one is straight from the camera. I love the mood of this pic. It was dark and cloudy...and I just love it!

#1.

#2. This looks a little better, right? However it did lose some of that dark, moody feel...
#3.
#4.
#5. This one reminds me of a painting...or something..lol..
So, you tell me...do you understand my random babblings...Do you ever experience this problem, or am I just weird?! If I could, I would print each of those and put them all over my house....but I won't. In fact I probably won't print any at all..

Which one do you like? Any suggestions on how to edit? Just want to say hi? Please do...thanks all! :)